There are four tables:
Table 1. Barrier Heights Calculated by LSDA, GGA, and Meta DFT Methods
Table 2. Barrier Heights Calculated by Hybrid DFT Methods
Table 3 Barrier Heights Calculated by Hybrid Meta DFT Methods
Table 4. Barrier Heights Calculated by Ab Initio WFT Methods
|
Reactions |
|
VSXC |
BB95 |
mPWPW91 |
TPSS |
BLYP |
SPW91 |
BP86 |
TPSSKCIS |
PBE |
mPWLYP |
mPWKCIS |
|
Heavy atom transfer reactions |
|
|
|
|
|
|
||||||
|
H + N2O → OH + N2 |
Vf≠ |
16.02 |
11.65 |
10.77 |
8.41 |
8.94 |
3.16 |
8.10 |
10.97 |
10.46 |
8.13 |
10.39 |
|
Vr≠ |
71.18 |
55.36 |
55.34 |
60.37 |
61.78 |
32.20 |
55.87 |
60.62 |
52.64 |
59.91 |
59.30 |
|
|
H + FH → HF + H |
Vf≠ |
36.75 |
29.71 |
28.57 |
27.33 |
26.77 |
19.40 |
26.00 |
29.15 |
27.98 |
25.94 |
28.59 |
|
Vr≠ |
36.75 |
29.71 |
28.57 |
27.33 |
26.77 |
19.40 |
26.00 |
29.15 |
27.98 |
25.94 |
28.59 |
|
|
H + ClH → HCl + H |
Vf≠ |
17.40 |
12.25 |
10.92 |
8.21 |
10.57 |
3.02 |
8.41 |
11.59 |
10.45 |
10.01 |
11.38 |
|
Vr≠ |
17.40 |
12.25 |
10.92 |
8.21 |
10.57 |
3.02 |
8.41 |
11.59 |
10.45 |
10.01 |
11.38 |
|
|
H + FCH3 → HF + CH3 |
Vf≠ |
21.79 |
19.78 |
18.94 |
17.35 |
16.33 |
13.62 |
16.25 |
18.98 |
18.74 |
15.56 |
18.04 |
|
Vr≠ |
51.65 |
41.88 |
42.48 |
42.17 |
42.33 |
31.78 |
42.55 |
42.43 |
41.14 |
40.62 |
43.75 |
|
|
H + F2 → HF + F |
Vf≠ |
-6.98 |
-8.87 |
-9.41 |
-10.72 |
-11.49 |
-15.75 |
-11.15 |
-9.10 |
-9.63 |
-12.30 |
-9.99 |
|
Vr≠ |
96.18 |
80.73 |
81.92 |
82.97 |
81.63 |
68.95 |
82.24 |
82.81 |
80.34 |
79.90 |
83.16 |
|
|
CH3 + FCl → CH3F +Cl |
Vf≠ |
-6.99 |
-6.23 |
-5.68 |
-5.35 |
-6.94 |
-11.47 |
-5.87 |
-5.95 |
-6.42 |
-8.33 |
-5.85 |
|
Vr≠ |
45.59 |
41.23 |
43.44 |
43.93 |
42.80 |
36.87 |
43.05 |
43.36 |
42.71 |
41.52 |
43.44 |
|
|
Nucleophilic substitution reactions |
||||||||||||
|
F- + CH3F → FCH3 + F- |
Vf≠ |
-7.63 |
-6.76 |
-7.74 |
-8.93 |
-7.88 |
-12.17 |
-7.57 |
-8.74 |
-8.33 |
-9.48 |
-7.35 |
|
Vr≠ |
-7.63 |
-6.76 |
-7.74 |
-8.93 |
-7.88 |
-12.17 |
-7.57 |
-8.74 |
-8.33 |
-9.48 |
-7.35 |
|
|
F-∙∙∙CH3F → FCH3 ∙∙∙ F- |
Vf≠ |
12.00 |
6.94 |
6.53 |
5.74 |
6.11 |
6.28 |
6.34 |
5.95 |
6.66 |
5.88 |
6.74 |
|
Vr≠ |
12.00 |
6.94 |
6.53 |
5.74 |
6.11 |
6.28 |
6.34 |
5.95 |
6.66 |
5.88 |
6.74 |
|
|
Cl- + CH3Cl → ClCH3 + Cl- |
Vf≠ |
-4.09 |
-2.59 |
-3.37 |
-5.09 |
-3.88 |
-6.67 |
-3.62 |
-4.52 |
-3.74 |
-5.05 |
-3.18 |
|
Vr≠ |
-4.09 |
-2.59 |
-3.37 |
-5.09 |
-3.88 |
-6.67 |
-3.62 |
-4.52 |
-3.74 |
-5.05 |
-3.18 |
|
|
Cl-∙∙∙CH3Cl → ClCH3∙∙∙Cl- |
Vf≠ |
10.83 |
6.79 |
6.63 |
5.26 |
5.55 |
6.54 |
6.13 |
5.74 |
6.92 |
5.40 |
6.62 |
|
Vr≠ |
10.83 |
6.79 |
6.63 |
5.26 |
5.55 |
6.54 |
6.13 |
5.74 |
6.92 |
5.40 |
6.62 |
|
|
F- + CH3Cl → FCH3 + Cl- |
Vf≠ |
-20.29 |
-17.99 |
-22.65 |
-21.14 |
-24.24 |
-23.34 |
-19.17 |
-20.48 |
-19.52 |
-20.73 |
-18.63 |
|
Vr≠ |
12.96 |
13.38 |
8.95 |
13.44 |
7.97 |
9.81 |
13.17 |
13.17 |
12.10 |
11.55 |
13.00 |
|
|
F-∙∙∙CH3Cl → FCH3∙∙∙Cl- |
Vf≠ |
-4.35 |
-1.38 |
-0.23 |
-0.33 |
-4.27 |
-1.24 |
-1.63 |
-2.23 |
-0.98 |
-2.04 |
-1.21 |
|
Vr≠ |
26.59 |
21.17 |
17.25 |
21.99 |
15.80 |
21.19 |
21.14 |
21.74 |
21.04 |
20.42 |
21.20 |
|
|
|
Vf≠ |
-9.58 |
-8.91 |
-10.11 |
-10.84 |
-9.78 |
-14.47 |
-9.65 |
-10.69 |
-10.67 |
-11.41 |
-9.58 |
|
Vr≠ |
10.53 |
10.86 |
10.22 |
8.35 |
9.59 |
6.21 |
10.03 |
8.61 |
9.63 |
8.02 |
10.46 |
|
|
OH-∙∙∙CH3F → HOCH3∙∙∙F- |
Vf≠ |
10.19 |
3.79 |
3.17 |
2.78 |
3.20 |
3.05 |
3.22 |
3.01 |
3.37 |
2.97 |
3.56 |
|
Vr≠ |
39.20 |
40.93 |
42.39 |
40.02 |
39.80 |
47.14 |
42.02 |
40.00 |
42.72 |
39.72 |
41.32 |
|
|
Unimolecular and Association Reaction |
||||||||||||
|
H + N2 → HN2 |
Vf≠ |
10.27 |
7.28 |
5.88 |
3.27 |
5.59 |
-1.85 |
3.43 |
6.34 |
5.57 |
5.04 |
6.08 |
|
Vr≠ |
11.88 |
8.64 |
9.36 |
8.51 |
8.58 |
9.53 |
9.47 |
9.15 |
9.23 |
8.64 |
9.37 |
|
|
H + CO → HCO |
Vf≠ |
2.15 |
-0.49 |
-1.40 |
-4.98 |
-1.93 |
-7.56 |
-3.37 |
-1.49 |
-1.69 |
-2.39 |
-1.41 |
|
Vr≠ |
26.23 |
23.56 |
24.82 |
23.71 |
23.36 |
26.36 |
24.99 |
24.77 |
24.72 |
23.45 |
24.66 |
|
|
H + C2H4 → CH3CH2 |
Vf≠ |
2.66 |
0.87 |
0.19 |
-4.17 |
-0.61 |
-5.24 |
-1.89 |
-0.29 |
-0.04 |
-1.06 |
0.00 |
|
Vr≠ |
43.38 |
37.71 |
40.72 |
40.02 |
38.29 |
39.40 |
40.93 |
40.90 |
40.39 |
38.17 |
40.40 |
|
|
CH3 + C2H4 → CH3CH2CH2 |
Vf≠ |
3.96 |
3.00 |
2.69 |
3.31 |
4.75 |
-5.72 |
2.69 |
3.54 |
1.57 |
3.41 |
4.01 |
|
Vr≠ |
25.36 |
26.56 |
29.15 |
27.84 |
24.88 |
32.97 |
28.47 |
27.37 |
29.72 |
25.05 |
27.25 |
|
|
HCN → HNC |
Vf≠ |
47.52 |
45.67 |
46.33 |
47.65 |
47.04 |
45.16 |
45.83 |
47.72 |
45.95 |
47.00 |
46.95 |
|
Vr≠ |
33.30 |
30.77 |
31.33 |
32.31 |
32.10 |
31.08 |
31.14 |
32.17 |
30.97 |
32.12 |
31.78 |
|
aVf≠ denotes forward barrier height, and Vr≠ denotes reverse barrier height.
bMG3S basis set and QCISD/MG3 geometries are used for all calculations in this table.
|
Reactions |
|
MPW1K |
B97-2 |
BHandHLYP |
mPW1PW91 |
B98 |
B97-1 |
PBE1PBE |
X3LYP |
B3LYP |
O3LYP |
|
Heavy-atom transfer reactions |
|||||||||||
|
H + N2O → OH + N2 |
Vf≠ |
17.16 |
18.69 |
16.08 |
14.65 |
15.43 |
16.37 |
14.44 |
11.74 |
11.81 |
12.65 |
|
Vr≠ |
81.63 |
72.36 |
91.27 |
71.24 |
74.10 |
72.62 |
68.97 |
73.01 |
72.92 |
66.93 |
|
|
H + FH → HF + H |
Vf≠ |
39.72 |
41.01 |
39.28 |
35.17 |
38.10 |
38.91 |
34.71 |
31.79 |
31.83 |
32.45 |
|
Vr≠ |
39.72 |
41.01 |
39.28 |
35.17 |
38.10 |
38.91 |
34.71 |
31.79 |
31.83 |
32.45 |
|
|
H + ClH → HCl + H |
Vf≠ |
||||||||||